Alumni Advocacy for Recruitment: Why the First Ask Should Not Be a Donation

Alumni advocacy for recruitment may be one of the most valuable enrollment resources Christian colleges already have, yet many institutions begin the relationship with the wrong request.

They ask alumni to give.

I understand why.

Advancement teams face ambitious fundraising goals, limited staff capacity, and constant pressure to find new sources of support.

Enrollment teams are working under similar pressure as they try to reach more students in a shrinking and increasingly competitive market.

Everyone needs results, and nobody has extra time or budget to spare.

But when every alumni communication seems to lead toward another financial appeal, graduates can begin to feel more like funding sources than members of a community.

New research from NACCAP and the Council for Christian Colleges & Universities suggests that alumni are open to deeper involvement.

Many simply want a different invitation.

They want opportunities to pray, attend events, speak to students, mentor, and share what they have learned.

Those relational and experiential opportunities can rebuild alumni connection while giving enrollment teams something they urgently need: credible advocates who can help prospective students see the lasting value of the institution.

The path forward begins by changing the order of the ask.

---

---

The Alumni Advocacy for Recruitment Gap Colleges Cannot Ignore

The 2025 NACCAP and CCCU market research revealed a striking difference between alumni support for Christian higher education and support for their own institutions.

One way the research measured that difference was through a Net Promoter Score, often called NPS.

NPS is a simple way to measure how likely people are to recommend an organization, product, or experience to someone else.

Respondents are usually asked a question like, “How likely are you to recommend this college to a friend or family member?”

They answer on a scale from 0 to 10.

In the NACCAP and CCCU research, alumni were asked whether they would recommend attending a Christian college or university.

The Net Promoter Score was 30.74.

But when alumni were asked whether they would recommend their own alma mater, the score dropped to 10.95.

That gap deserves careful attention.

Alumni appear to believe in the larger idea of Christian higher education more strongly than they believe in the experience their own institution delivered.

That gap should prompt colleges to listen before they respond.

A recommendation score can show that something needs attention, but it cannot explain what alumni are carrying with them.

Some may still feel grateful for their education but disconnected from the institution today.

Others may have unresolved disappointment from their student experience.

Some may admire the college’s mission but feel unsure about recommending it because of cost, career outcomes, communication, leadership changes, or a lack of ongoing relationship after graduation.

That is why the recommendation question should be followed with careful listening:

• What shaped your answer?
• What has strengthened or weakened your connection since graduation?
• Where did the institution serve you well?
• Where did it fall short?
• What would make you more comfortable recommending the college today?
• How would you like to participate in the institution’s mission now?

The goal is not to defend the institution or talk an alumnus out of a disappointing experience.

The goal is to understand what alumni are saying, respond where appropriate, and rebuild a healthier relationship going forward.

Why a Donation-First Model Misses the Moment

Fundraising remains essential to the health of a college.

Scholarships, academic programs, faculty support, facilities, and student services all depend on generous donors.

But financial giving is only one expression of alumni commitment.

The NACCAP and CCCU research found that just 16% of surveyed alumni selected donations as one of the ways they would most like to remain involved.

By comparison, 48% were interested in praying for the college and its students.

Another 36% wanted to attend in-person events or reunions, 31% wanted to speak to a class or student group, 24% were interested in mentoring, and 22% wanted to participate in an alumni panel or webinar.

Those numbers point to a practical problem.

Many institutions are emphasizing the form of engagement alumni select less often while under-developing the experiences they prefer.

The Council for Advancement and Support of Education offers a helpful broader definition.

Its Alumni Engagement Metrics framework measures engagement in four modes: communication, experiential involvement, volunteering, and philanthropy.

That framework places a gift in its proper context.

Giving matters, but so do relationships, experiences, service, and communication.

“Alumni engage in multiple ways.” — CASE

When an institution measures alumni relationship success almost entirely by dollars raised, it overlooks graduates who may be willing to give their time, expertise, influence, prayers, and personal credibility.

Those contributions can have real value for recruitment.

Young Alumni Need Invitations That Fit Their Current Reality

The donation-first approach is particularly difficult for young alumni.

Only 17% of younger alumni in the NACCAP and CCCU study had donated to their alma mater, compared with 60% of older alumni.

Sixty-five percent of younger alumni said they could not afford to give at the time of the survey.

That does not necessarily mean they have rejected their institution.

They may be repaying student loans, beginning careers, moving to new communities, raising young families, or trying to establish financial stability.

A large gift may be unrealistic, but a one-hour virtual career panel may be entirely possible.

An institution that recognizes this difference can invite young alumni into meaningful participation without making them feel guilty about their bank accounts.

Consider offering opportunities such as:

• Mentoring one student for a semester.
• Speaking to a class about the first few years after graduation.
• Joining a virtual panel for students in the same major.
• Answering career questions during an alumni office hour.
• Welcoming admitted students from the same city or region.
• Recording a brief video about a professor or experience that shaped them.
• Helping with a service project, prayer gathering, or young alumni event.

Keep the commitment specific.

“Would you meet with one student for 30 minutes?” feels manageable.

“Would you like to volunteer with the college?” is vague and easy to ignore.

Young alumni are more likely to respond when they know what is being requested, why it matters, and how much time it will require.

Alumni Advocacy for Recruitment Starts With Meaningful Experiences

Alumni advocacy cannot be manufactured with a social media toolkit alone.

A college can provide sample posts, referral links, and branded graphics, but those materials will not create enthusiasm where connection is weak.

Advocacy grows when people have a relationship worth talking about.

An advocate needs more than instructions on how to tell others about you. They need an ongoing reason to care.

That reason might be the student they mentor.

It might be the faculty member they reconnect with during an event.

It might be the chance to share professional wisdom with a class.

It might be seeing how a scholarship helped a student with a familiar story.

These experiences turn institutional updates into personal connections.

They also create natural opportunities for alumni to support recruitment.

A mentor can explain the value of the college’s career network.

A classroom speaker can show students how a degree connects with a real vocation.

An alumnus at an admissions event can answer questions with a level of honesty and credibility an institutional representative cannot reproduce.

A graduate who shares a career story can give prospective families concrete evidence of an educational outcome.

The NACCAP and CCCU research found that awareness of Christian colleges often begins through personal networks.

About 70% of enrolled students knew someone who had attended a Christian college, and 76% identified that person as a friend.

The research concluded that credibility comes through personal proximity rather than polished institutional messaging.

Alumni can expand that network of trusted voices.

The Role of Alumni in Student Recruitment

The role of alumni in student recruitment extends beyond referrals.

Referrals matter, but alumni can support students at several points in the enrollment journey.

Awareness

Alumni introduce the college through everyday conversations in churches, workplaces, schools, community groups, and families.

They can also share authentic stories through their personal social networks.

Consideration

Prospective students want evidence that a college’s promises continue beyond graduation.

Alumni can discuss career preparation, mentoring, spiritual formation, friendships, and the transition into adult life.

Decision

An admitted student may benefit from speaking with a graduate who studied the same subject, came from the same region, or had similar concerns.

That conversation can make the institution feel less abstract.

Enrollment and belonging

Alumni can welcome incoming students, connect them with professional communities, and show that joining the college means entering a relationship that continues after commencement.

This work supports mission-fit recruitment.

The aim is not to persuade every student to enroll.

It is to help the right students gain an honest view of the experience, outcomes, community, and mission they are considering.

Build a Relationship-to-Advocacy Pathway

Colleges need a clear path that helps alumni move from occasional contact to meaningful advocacy.

I recommend five stages.

1. Listen

Begin by learning how alumni feel about the institution now.

Ask a simple recommendation question, then follow it with open-ended questions that help explain the answer.

Do not rely on a single score or survey result.

Pair the data with interviews, focus groups, event conversations, and engagement patterns so your team can understand what alumni are actually experiencing.

Then look for meaningful differences by graduation year, academic program, geography, current involvement, and past participation.

A recent graduate may need a different invitation than someone who graduated 35 years ago.

One alumnus may be ready to mentor.

Another may need to be heard first.

The point is to understand the relationship before deciding what kind of invitation comes next.

2. Reconnect

Offer experiences that restore a sense of belonging.

These might include regional gatherings, faculty conversations, prayer opportunities, career communities, reunions, webinars, or events built around shared interests.

A newsletter can keep alumni informed, but information alone does not create a relationship.

Create opportunities for alumni to participate rather than simply consume updates.

3. Contribute

Make it easy for alumni to contribute something they already possess.

That might be time, experience, professional knowledge, hospitality, prayer, or access to a community.

Match the invitation to the person.

A teacher might speak with prospective education majors.

A pastor might host a regional information gathering.

A business owner might provide an internship.

A recent graduate might answer candid questions about the transition from college to career.

4. Advocate

Once alumni are involved, invite them to help prospective students.

Provide enough structure to make participation comfortable, but do not script away their honesty.

Alumni advocacy works because graduates can talk about both the strengths of the institution and the real work required to thrive there.

That honest perspective builds trust.

5. Give

Financial support remains an important invitation.

But it now comes within a broader relationship.

An alumnus who has seen the effect of a mentoring program or spoken with current scholarship recipients has a clearer understanding of what a gift can accomplish.

The financial ask becomes connected to people and outcomes rather than an institutional need stated in isolation.

In Chasing Mission Fit, I describe this as “friendraising” before fundraising.

The aim is to earn trust and friendship, then discuss financial support when the relationship and timing are right.

How to Improve Alumni NPS

Improving alumni NPS requires more than running yet another survey.

The institution must improve the alumni relationship that the score reflects.

Start with three practical steps.

First, identify the experiences driving promoter, passive, and detractor scores.

Do not assume every low score has the same cause.

Some alumni may be disappointed by their student experience.

Others may have concerns about current institutional direction, poor communication, political perceptions, weak career support, or the loss of relationships after graduation.

Second, create a process for responding.

A detractor who offers thoughtful feedback should hear from a real person when appropriate.

A passive alumnus who indicates an interest in mentoring should receive an actual invitation, rather than another general newsletter.

Third, measure behavior alongside sentiment.

Track whether alumni attend events, volunteer, mentor students, refer prospects, contribute stories, participate in admissions programs, and eventually give.

NPS is one signal.

The relationship is the larger story.

Measure Alumni Engagement Beyond Donations

A broader strategy needs a broader scorecard.

Consider tracking:

• Alumni Net Promoter Score (NPS) by graduation cohort.
• Reasons behind promoter, passive, and detractor ratings.
• Event attendance and repeat attendance.
• Mentor and mentee participation.
• Alumni classroom speakers and panelists.
• Alumni stories collected and published.
• Prospective student referrals.
• Admissions events supported by alumni.
• Conversations between alumni and admitted students.
• Volunteer participation by program and geography.
• Movement from experiential involvement to volunteering or giving.

These measures give enrollment, advancement, alumni relations, career services, and marketing a shared view of the relationship.

That shared view matters.

An alumnus may attend a career event organized by one department, speak to a class through another, appear in an admissions video, and later support a scholarship.

The institution needs systems that recognize the whole relationship.

Extend Your Community Beyond Commencement

Christian colleges often describe community as one of their greatest strengths.

Students remember close friendships, faculty mentors, spiritual formation, and the sense that they belonged to something larger than themselves.

That promise should not expire when a graduate crosses the commencement stage.

The NACCAP and CCCU executive summary found that alumni with positive student experiences who still feel connected are four times more likely to volunteer or give.

The report concludes that lasting support requires sustained community and meaningful engagement, rather than solicitation alone.

That is the opportunity in front of us.

Alumni do not have to choose between being donors and advocates. Many will become both over the course of their relationship with the institution.

But colleges will build stronger advocacy when they first invite graduates to belong, participate, and serve.

Start with a better question.

Instead of asking only, “Will you give?”

Ask, “How would you like to help the next student experience the community that shaped you?”

The answers may strengthen alumni relationships, improve institutional advocacy, and introduce more mission-fit students to your college.

For additional practical ideas, read 10 Alumni Engagement Ideas to Support Your Enrollment Goals.

Build an Alumni Advocacy Strategy That Supports Enrollment

Alumni relationships often stretch across advancement, marketing, admissions, career services, academic departments, and institutional leadership.

Without a shared strategy, graduates can receive disconnected messages, repeated requests, or invitations that overlook how they actually want to participate.

Caylor Solutions helps colleges assess their current marketing and engagement efforts, identify gaps, clarify audience segments, and develop practical strategies tied to enrollment and advancement goals.

Our Marketing Audit and Recommendations service can help your team examine the alumni communication journey, while our Content Strategy and Marketing services can turn alumni experiences into credible stories that reach mission-fit students.

Your alumni already understand your institution from the inside.

Give them meaningful ways to remain part of its future.

Talk with Caylor Solutions about building a coordinated alumni advocacy and enrollment strategy.

---

Think Your Website Is “Broken”?

It might be time to redesign your enrollment website to get the results you’re looking for.

Download our free Guide to Website Redesign Planning to learn more about how to fix the most common problems school websites have.

In this guide, you’ll explore how to…

• • Tell your school’s story
  • Focus your website for maximum results
  • Write powerful web copy
  • Automate your website to do more in less time, and more!

Don’t revamp your website before you check out our free Guide to Website Redesign Planning!

And if you want to go deeper to see how much more you can get out of your enrollment website, contact us for a consultation and a digital marketing audit.

images via chatgpt