AI Marketing Leadership in Higher Ed: The CMO’s New Job
AI marketing leadership in higher ed requires strategy, judgment, and cross-campus alignment. Here’s a practical plan for CMOs and VPs.
Branding
While many colleges and universities are struggling to maintain enrollment, Carthage College is showing us what’s possible when sustainable enrollment growth becomes a campus-wide priority.
It’s no secret that higher education is facing some significant challenges.
The demographic cliff, rising skepticism about the value of college, changing student behaviors, and increasing competition have enrollment leaders wondering how they’ll fill next year’s class.
For many institutions, simply maintaining enrollment feels like a victory.
But what if you could do more than maintain your numbers? What if you could grow your enrollment year after year without compromising the student experience?
That’s exactly what’s happening at Carthage College in Kenosha, Wisconsin.
In fall 2025, Carthage welcomed 926 freshmen, up from 777 the previous year. That’s an increase of nearly 20%!
And in fall 2026, Carthage followed that record-breaking class with another record, enrolling approximately 30 additional freshmen.
What makes this story particularly interesting is that Carthage isn’t relying on some secret enrollment marketing strategy that nobody else knows about.
Instead, they’re doing many of the things we already know work in higher education enrollment strategies. They’re just approaching them with greater intentionality, collaboration, and consistency.

Ashley has spent nearly two decades at Carthage, working her way through multiple admissions leadership roles. She’s seen firsthand what works, what doesn’t, and what happens when an entire campus commits to enrollment success.
And here’s the biggest takeaway from our conversation: Sustainable enrollment growth doesn’t come from one silver bullet. It comes from doing the right things consistently, improving them every year, and getting everyone working toward the same goals.
One of the most important things Ashley shared was that enrollment success at Carthage isn’t simply the responsibility of the admissions office.
It’s everyone’s responsibility.
Over the past six years, Carthage has grown its overall student body by approximately 9%. That’s significant growth for a private liberal arts college in today’s enrollment environment.
But Ashley is quick to point out that the admissions team didn’t accomplish that alone.
Their success comes from intentional collaboration between admissions, marketing, athletics, faculty, student services, and institutional leadership.
Too often, I see colleges treat enrollment as something that happens in one building on campus.
The admissions office recruits students. Marketing produces materials. Faculty teach classes. Athletics recruits athletes.
And everyone operates in their own silo.
Unfortunately, that’s not how prospective students experience your institution!
They’re watching how faculty interact with them, how coaches communicate, and whether the people they meet seem genuinely interested in their success.
That’s why campus-wide enrollment collaboration is so important.
At Carthage, Ashley’s team has worked to establish shared goals, communicate enrollment data across campus, and create processes that make collaboration repeatable.
That last part is particularly important.
You can’t build a sustainable recruitment strategy around occasionally asking a friendly professor to attend an admissions event.
Carthage has leadership support from the president’s office down, helping departments understand that they’re all contributing to the same institutional mission.
And that alignment allows everyone to approach enrollment with a common purpose.
The takeaway for enrollment leaders is simple: If you want better results, don’t just ask what your admissions team needs to change.
Ask what your entire campus can do differently to help prospective students see themselves succeeding at your institution.
As institutions grow, there’s a temptation to focus on scale.
More inquiries. More applications. More campus visits.
And those metrics certainly matter.
But one of the things I appreciated most about Ashley’s approach is that Carthage hasn’t allowed increasing volume to diminish the personal experience.
In fact, their campus visits increased by approximately 20% the year before their applications jumped.
Despite that growth, Carthage continues to prioritize personalized student recruitment.
Ashley explained that the goal is for every visiting student to have an opportunity to connect with a faculty member or coach.
Think about how powerful that can be!
Rather than simply hearing an admissions counselor describe the academic experience, a prospective nursing student can meet someone involved in that program.
An aspiring athlete can talk directly with a coach.
And a first-generation student who doesn’t even know what questions to ask can receive guidance without having to request it.
That’s an important distinction.
Sometimes we assume prospective students will tell us exactly what they need. But many students and families are navigating the college search for the first time.
They don’t know what’s available or what they should be asking.
Carthage also uses virtual events, academic-interest programming, and on-demand webinars to create additional opportunities for engagement.
And then there’s my favorite little detail from our conversation. Gummy bears!
Because Carthage is located near the Haribo facility in Wisconsin, visiting students receive a bag of gummy bears.
It sounds simple, doesn’t it?
But sometimes a small, tangible experience creates a more memorable connection than another financial incentive that looks exactly like what every other college offers.
I love this because it demonstrates something I’ve discussed with institutions for years.
You don’t always need a bigger budget to create a better experience. You need to understand what matters to your students.
The little things add up.
And when you combine personalized attention with memorable experiences and intentional follow-up, you’re building the relationships that ultimately contribute to college enrollment growth.
Another critical component of Carthage’s sustainable enrollment growth is its willingness to challenge traditional recruitment assumptions.
Student search behavior is changing.
Prospective students aren’t necessarily filling out inquiry forms or identifying themselves early in the college decision process.
They’re researching institutions independently, consuming digital content, and increasingly using AI-powered tools to explore their options.
That creates a challenge for enrollment marketers who have traditionally relied on purchased names and predictable inquiry funnels.
For Carthage, part of the answer is showing up earlier in the places students already spend their time.
One example Ashley shared is the institution’s use of NextGrad, which places digital advertising within high schools.
Carthage was an early adopter of the platform and now participates in approximately 10 to 15 high schools annually, depending on its marketing strategy.
What Ashley likes about this approach is the flexibility.
Rather than displaying the same message for months, Carthage can rotate creative content and respond to changing market conditions.
That matters because students need repeated opportunities to encounter your institution before they’re ready to take action.
In my book Chasing Mission Fit, I talk about finding the watering holes where your prospective students spend time.
But awareness is only part of the equation.
Once students discover your school, you have to give them meaningful reasons to consider attending.
That’s where Carthage’s Aspire program comes into play.
Ashley explained:
A few years ago, we revamped our career services. We don’t even use the term career services anymore. Now, we have what’s called the Aspire program.
Starting at day zero, a student is assigned a career specialist, somebody from their field, an industry expert that they will work with throughout their four years. We use the Aspire team as an arm for our recruitment. Our Aspire team speaks at our scholarship events and hosts webinars.
I love how Carthage has taken something that many colleges treat as a service students discover later and made it a central part of their enrollment messaging.
Career specialists participate in scholarship events and webinars, helping prospective students understand the connection between their education and their future careers.
Once students enroll, career development continues through activities embedded in the curriculum, an app that tracks progress, and opportunities to earn badges and graduation cords.
The program’s services also extend beyond graduation.
This is a great example of connecting the value proposition of your institution to the things families actually care about.
Students aren’t simply asking what they’ll study.
They’re asking what their investment will help them become.
And schools that can demonstrate those outcomes throughout the recruitment process have an opportunity to build stronger connections with mission-fit students.
Here’s something we don’t talk about enough in higher education marketing.
Growing enrollment creates new challenges.
And if you’re not prepared to address them, enrollment growth can quickly become a problem rather than a success.
Ashley shared how Carthage has had to make some creative decisions to accommodate its larger student population.
Housing is one example.
With more students wanting to live on campus, Carthage needed additional options without immediately committing to building another residence hall.
The college partnered with a downtown Kenosha hotel to provide optional housing for upperclassmen.
It also established shuttle transportation between downtown and campus.
Rather than treating additional housing capacity as a problem that required a permanent construction project, Carthage found a flexible solution.
Ashley also described weekly housing meetings involving enrollment, student affairs, residential life, academic leadership, and the president’s office.
I appreciate this approach because it’s proactive rather than reactive.
And that’s where understanding your market becomes so important.
For example, Carthage has recognized that commuter students represent an increasingly important audience.
In fall 2026, approximately 22% of the incoming freshman class commuted from home.
Carthage also experienced approximately 20% growth in its freshman enrollment from Kenosha County compared with the prior year.
Instead of trying to position every student as a traditional residential student, Carthage communicates the opportunities available to both commuters and residents.
The institution hasn’t abandoned its residential identity.
It’s simply recognizing that different students need different pathways to access the Carthage experience.
The same thinking applies to affordability.
Ashley explained that approximately one-third of Carthage students are Pell-eligible and that the institution’s Carthage Commitment helps eligible students cover their out-of-pocket costs.
These details matter because they challenge outdated assumptions about who can attend a private college.
But one of Ashley’s strongest messages was about the danger of copying other institutions.
Higher education leaders love talking about best practices.
We attend conferences, study successful schools, and try to replicate what works.
There’s nothing wrong with learning from other institutions.
The problem comes when we forget to consider whether those approaches make sense for our own students, institutional mission, and resources.
Carthage’s story demonstrates why higher education enrollment strategies must be adapted to the specific institution, rather than adopted simply because they’re popular.
One of my favorite moments in this conversation came when Ashley explained what sustainable growth really requires.
She said:
Don’t be afraid of who you are. Sell that [to your prospective students].
So many schools think they want to be something [different than they are]. How do we change that narrative? Own it. Own [all the things that make you unique] and get that message out there.
The other thing that just resonates with me so well is that every year we have to keep doing what we did last year [even if we] add these next five strategies on top of it. I don’t see that changing for the next five to six years.
I think that’s a powerful reminder for every enrollment and marketing leader.
Too often, we’re looking for the next big thing that will suddenly transform our enrollment results.
A new CRM. A new advertising platform. A new academic program. A new recruitment campaign.
And sometimes those investments absolutely make sense.
You have to keep doing the things that work while finding ways to make them more efficient and effective.
You also need to know when to stop doing things that no longer serve your students.
For institutions looking to build that kind of momentum, I’d start with five priorities:
These aren’t necessarily revolutionary ideas.
But Carthage College demonstrates what can happen when you execute them consistently.
Ashley shared so many valuable insights that we couldn’t possibly cover everything in one blog post.
Listen to our full conversation for more on:
Ready to Build a More Sustainable Enrollment Strategy?
At Caylor Solutions, we help colleges and universities develop mission-fit marketing strategies that attract the right students, strengthen recruitment messaging, and connect marketing efforts to enrollment goals.
Whether you’re looking to improve your digital marketing, communicate your institution’s unique value, or create a more effective recruitment strategy, we’d love to help you find the right approach for your school.
Let’s talk about how Caylor Solutions can help your institution build sustainable enrollment growth.
Then you’ve got to know how to write for the web. That’s why we want to send you our popular ebook: Writing for the Web: 7 Secrets to Content Marketing Success for Education Marketers!
With this helpful resource, you’ll learn how to:
In short, you’ll be able to write the copy that makes your digital marketing strategy work for you. Download your copy today!
images via carthage.edu
Subscribe to The Higher Ed Marketer podcast today!